Megan McArdle

« Nearly one-third of mortgages responsible for nearly one third of defaults. Reel at 11. | Main | Oh, what a tangled web »

What about this Bush plan?

31 Aug 2007 10:42 am

The administration has announced a plan to help borrowers in danger of default. Broadly, the terms seem to be:


1) Increasing the number of homeowners the FHA can insure, which will help them refinance at lower rates. The FHA (Federal Housing Administration) doesn't offer loans itself; it just helps people with shaky credit or financials qualify for mortgages by guaranteeing to pick up the tab in case of default.

2) Suspending the tax penalty for people who get their loan values reduced. Normally, the IRS taxes any such reduction, in order to prevent companies from giving their employees "loans" which they then "forgive" as a way of evading taxes on salaries. I wouldn't be precisely shocked if some valued employees with employer-sponsored loans, but without financial problems, see their debt reduced during the tax holiday.

3) A joint initiative between Treasury and HUD to offer as-yet-unspecified help to people in danger of defaulting.

Overall, this seems to me like a pretty good package. It doesn't, as many of the more generous plans do, offer irresponsible borrowers free home equity at the expense of either the lender or the taxpayer. But it does give them a chance to get some breathing space by working out terms with their lender. And it stops the rather horrid practice of taxing people who've had to sell their house for less than the value of the mortgage.

Of course, one wonders how much help the Treasury/HUD initiative will really be--it may just consist of Federal employees saying, in stentorian tones, "You sure do have more house than you can afford, there." But overall, it seems like a pretty good package, and the expense to the taxpayer seems admirably minimized.

Comments (2)

P O'Neill

Maybe the details read better than the Bush announcement sounded like. It was strongly reminiscent of these occasional Wars on Price Gouging that we're promised when the price of gas gets "too high."

2 sounds very good and fair (although probably open to abuse). 1 sounds like it opens up the possibility of a remake of the Savings and Loan fiasco. Maybe the details will make it sound better.

When is it going to occur to Democratic politicians (or will it ever?) that the deflation of house prices would provide immediate "affordable housing" to millions of Americans? It's time for the end of the 400K starter home.

Comments on this entry have been closed.