« Tax hatred has a long pedigree | Main | Go Yankees! Ish! »

I'm sure you're right

28 Sep 2007 03:36 pm

Yesterday, I sat through a friend's fifteen minute disquisition on comic-book trends, delivered as if I, too, regularly read the things. Though he later apologized, I genuinely enjoyed it; there's something interesting about sitting through someone else's abstruse technical discussions. It's a little window into a world that is normally totally invisible to your view.

Today, I enjoyed the same phenomenon reading another friend blog about cricket:


The best one may say for Twenty20 is that it may prove a gateway to an appreciation of real cricket for some fans; much more likely, however, is that it will further erode the viability of test match cricket which is already in trouble everywhere outside England and Australia.

This is not merely a question of money, but ones of technique, discipline and mental fortitude. One day cricket alters the way batsmen and bowlers approach the game. How many batsmen now have the patience, let alone the technique required, to bat all day on a difficult wicket? Precious few. How many bowlers, used to being smashed off a length in hit-and-run cricket, now possess the ability to stick to line and length? Precious few.

It may be silly to think there was once a golden age - Cardus after all mourned the pre-1914 game even as he was writing about Bradman and Hammond and Woolley and Headley and all the rest - but skills once considered integral to the game are disappearing and part of the blame for that must be apportioned to the proliferation of one-day cricket.

Right ho.

Comments (12)

I demand a post about said comic book trends

s'ok Megan... I'm sure there are a lot of people who would raise an eyebrow to anyone who used abstruse in a sentence... What I find worthwhile about people who have other interests, is the sheer passion of them. Don't care if it's a discussion of Biblical sentence structure, a discussion of subtitled versus dubbed anime, or if it's worth indexing sparkplugs in a hemi. If you are a truly active listener, chance are you will pick up much knowledge just from asking questions. In addition to maybe being the only person willing to listen to theories about why or not The Illiad should still be required reading... you may also find a person willing to listen about your exploits in blowing little clay birds to bits, even if talking about guns normally gives them hives.

Did it involve The Green Lantern theory of geopolitics?

"What I find worthwhile about people who have other interests, is the sheer passion of them. "

I think the book Longitude is credited with becoming a best seller based solely on the author's infectious enthusiasm.

As an interesting convergence, I read the blog (well... livejournal) of an Australian Webcomic author and cricket fanatic, who has gotten me interested in cricket enough to listen to a few matches on BBC Radio. The biannual series between England and Australia ("The Ashes") is always particularly interesting. It has now become a life goal of mine to play the position of Silly Mid Off in a cricket game.

Translation. If the other team has a stud pitcher , tire him out and get to the bullpen. Scoring is secondary.

What's your point?

Nah, that's not a very good translation.

Translation: Imagine a variant of baseball where, rather than each team getting 27 outs, the game ends after a set number of strikes are thrown by each team's pitchers. (120 would be the precise analog with Twenty20, but in cricket outs take a lot longer to get, so we'll ignore outs, and no balls are rarer in cricket than balls in baseball.) The game might become more like a home run derby, and certainly players would stop working the count, wasting vital pitches. Would change things.

Another translation: I liked the contact hitter game of the deadball era with Ty Cobb, Tris Speaker, and Honus Wagner. That Babe Ruth and all his imitators have ruined the game, causing baseballers to swing for the fences instead of concentrating on well-placed hits. That the rules/equipment changed to encourage such behavior has only helped the atrophying of once beautiful skills.

Sounds like Klein listening to Greenspan?

You really should have watched Wales vs Fiji. Rugby game, World Cup, finished a few minutes ago. Phew what a scorcher. Scotland vs Italy later today. Argentina vs Ireland tomorrow.

I seem to recall Harry Davis at the Chicago GSB saying that when he flies he always picks up a couple of niche magazines - motocross, Christian parenting, hair metal, etc. Says it sparks creativity to immerse yourself in these little worlds for an hour or so.

xwyopr ambn rhknd fuqizpra dyfmgaco imzakg nhiogdylq

xwyopr ambn rhknd fuqizpra dyfmgaco imzakg nhiogdylq


Copyright © 2008 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.