« Comfort Inn, Jamaica, Queens Delenda Est | Main | A clarification »

Comfort Inn: No Comfort, No Inn

25 Oct 2007 02:43 pm

Remember, LORD, against Edom
that day at Jerusalem.
They said: "Raze it, Raze it
down to its very foundations!"
Oh, Comfort Inn, Jamaica, Queens
You destroyer
Happy be he who repays you
The evil you have done us

I had what I think could be fairly termed a very bad day yesterday. Only the end of it, of course. Everything started to go wrong at the exact moment, around 3:00, when my editor and I decided that I should go to upstate New York for a few days in order to round out a story I'm working on.

By 5:30, I had an airline ticket for 8 PM and a rental car. By 7PM, I was at the airport bright eyed and bushytailed, ready to jet off to the exotic wilds of Western New York State. By 12:30, I expected to be there, ready to report on the quaint customs of the locals. It was one of those glamorous journalist moments you often dream about, but rarely experience. Rolly bag in one hand, wallet in the other, I stuck my credit card in the slot and printed out my boarding passes.

Now, I am not particularly good at math; a little light calculus is about my speed. Nonetheless, when I saw that my flight from New York City to Rochester was scheduled to depart at 10:55, while my flight from Washington to New York City was not scheduled to take off until 10:44, I suspected that there might be some flaw in the planning. I also noticed, apropos of nothing in particular, that the takeoff time for my flight was some two hours and forty-four minutes after Jet Blue's preternaturally perky website had told me I could expect to be upping wheels. I presented my bewilderment to the desk clerk.

"That flight's delayed," she said, unecessarily. I explained about the connection. "Yes," she said, "there's no way you're getting to Rochester tonight." Weather up and down the East Coast, you see, was playing havoc with schedules.

I do not mean to paint her as callous. In fact, she was incredibly nice and apologetic, and spent 20 minutes in a tag-team strategy session during which flight times were checked, hotel sites consulted, and desired wake-up hours considered. Expedia informed me that I could stay in New York City near JFK for $152 a night, plus applicable taxes and fees. After considering that my alternative was to take a $60 cab ride back from Dulles, and then do the entire thing all over again the next morning at 4 am, the hotel room looked positively cheap. To be sure, it was a Comfort Inn, and Comfort Inns do not, in my experience, always live up to their name. But how bad could it be, I asked jauntily, clicking "book it now" and then marching off to security.

Do not, my children, ever speak those words out loud. You are challenging the travel gods to do their worst, And in these days of cavity searches and theological arguments over whether my prescription face cream is, or is not, a banned substance, their worst can be very, very bad indeed.

I suppose you have already guessed that my plane did not, in fact, take off at 10:44. By the time I had gotten to the gate, its ETD had already changed to 11:30. Subsequently, it would change to "Whenever the plane gets here from wherever the hell it is," which, for future reference, turns out to be sometime around 12:15.

I hadn't realized Dulles was so cold at night. The coffee gave out around 10, whereupon I was reduced to wrapping myself in every piece of clothing I'd brought and trying to sleep. I suspect that if I hadn't tidily thrown away my much-used coffee cup, some kind stranger would have dropped a quarter in it as I lay swaddled in sweatpants and herringbone tweed suit jackets. At 12:15 they boarded us. At 12:25, we took off. At 1:00, I stumbled out into the terminal and hailed a cab.

Where is the Comfort Inn, Jamaica? Asked my driver.

It is, I proudly informed him, having already memorized the address in the interest of maxmizing my sleep time before the 9:25 am flight to Rochester, at 87-05 Van Wyck.

Where is that? Asked my cab driver. I will note, in passing, for those who have not enjoyed the many benefits of residence in New York City, that the Van Wyck is the road to JFK. From the airport, it is about as hard to find as your own feet. Nonetheless, he called for directions.

I should have known. I should have known when, before they would give him directions, they asked him who he was.

You know what happened, don't you? You do. But you can't quite believe it. You've heard the urban legends, about hotels who give away the rooms of travelers on delayed flights, because someone else is willing to pay more money for them. But come on, you're thinking. They didn't really

At least, that's what you're thinking if you're anything like me. Indeed, the same thought kept running through my head as I listened numbly to the hotel clerk explain that she had had to cancel my reservation because she had been unable to charge my credit card, and had therefore thought that I was not coming.

You deadbeat, her voice said.

Let us dissect this a little. My Visa card, a worn but proud little piece of plastic with my alma matter's crest right on it (that in itself is a long story), is nowhere near its limits, because I'm one of those anti-debt freaks. Moreover, the credit card had already been authorised by Expedia, through which I booked the room. At 8 PM. What were the odds, really, that I had booked a (nonrefundable) room at 8PM and then decided not to come by 10PM?

Furthermore, the clerk had had a good four hours or so before I got on the plane in which to discover that the card was unchargeable and call me. This had not happened. When I pointed this out, the details of whom, exactly, she had tried to call became extraordinarily fuzzy. Maybe she hadn't tried to call me; maybe she'd just gotten bored waiting on hold to Expedia and hung up, and sold my room. But on one point she was crystal clear. She had tried to charge my credit card--twice!--and been unable to do so.


Over the next three minutes, I went through more emotions than a small-town amateur dramatics society doing Hamlet: the Musical. I wept. I cajoled. I threatened. I raged. I pleaded. All of which was no avail; she had no rooms. And the reason for her insistence that she couldn't charge my card became abruptly clear: since they hadn't charged the card, she said, they had no obligation to find me another one.

I a gesture of great munificence, she did finally give me the number of several other hotels in the area. You will not be surprised to hear . . . as indeed, I was not . . . that they had no rooms at 1:30 am, what with all the delayed flights.

So there I was sitting in a taxi at the mouth of the Van Wyck Expressway with no housing. I ordered the cab to take me back to the airport, paying $10 for the privilege of a private midnight tour of the Greater JFK Landscaping Program.

As he made his weary way back to the airport, I called the credit card company to find out what had happened. Why would they have declined the charge?

They hadn't, they said. Indeed, they had authorised a charge of $172.00, this being what $152 works out to after taxes, licensing, and applicable fees.

Perhaps that had been Expedia. Had the hotel attempted to authorise further charges and been declined?

They forwarded me to authorisations. Nope, no one had attempted to authorize any sort of charge, except the ones they'd approved.

Another call to the clerk, who kept on with her story. She'd tried to authorize the card, twice.

I pointed out, first, that the moral thing to do would be to find me another hotel room; and second, that I am a naturally vindictive person who was going to have a very long talk with customer service tomorrow about the hotel's booking practices. This was greeted with about as much interest as if she'd accidentally tuned into the gardening report. I tried to charge it, twice, she repeated . . .

(You debt-ridden hag. Maybe if you paid your bills, you wouldn't be huddled on the floor of an airport terminal at 2 am, trying to keep warm by wrapping your yoga tights around your exposed skin.)

I called Choice Hotels main reservation line. They chose to listen silently to my plight, offer to find me a room at the three hotels I had already discovered were booked solid, and let me go without regret.

At 2 am, I got Expedia involved. The Expedia phone rep, who seemed to be located somewhere in the Indian subcontinent, and therefore not close enough to do what I wanted him to, which was storm in like the gnome in the television commercials and save me, called the hotel. He returned to report that she had tried to charge the card, twice, to no avail.

I was, by this point, pretty much the only person left in the terminal. The guy sweeping the floors asked me why I didn't go home. I have no home, I replied sadly. However, the cavernous and deserted space did give my shouting into my now-dying cell phone a sort of echoing grandeur that helped put me in the correct righteous mood.

But they are lying, I said. The rep did that customer service rep thing where they don't say anything commital, but nonetheless convey the impression that you are a lunatic.

I checked with the card company, I said, twice. No one attempted a further authorization on the card after the first, successful one.

He remained noncommittal. He isn't there to judge. If my credit card bounces like Ricochet Rabbit, well, we all have hard times occasionally. The main thing now was to get me off the phone.

Of course, there was nothing the telephone guy could do anyway; it's not like they give their outsourcing center the power to shut hotels out of the network. But in the cold light of day, I do hope someone is taking a long, hard, look at the Comfort Inn, Jamaica, Queens.

Eventually, the Expedia clerk seemed to realize that this was not some customer complaining that the Ficus in her hotel room doesn't smell fresh, and that being as I was stuck in the terminal with nowhere to go, I had literally all night to prosecute my complaint. Once he grokked that finding me another hotel room was the best way to get off the phone, he sprang into action. He did not, alas, offer to pay for the extra charges thus incurred, but at least he tried to make sure I had, y'know, a blanket and some good ol' central heating.

Ah, central heating. You young people don't know how lucky you are . . .

The Expedia guy rapidly discovered what I already knew, which is that the reason the clerk had given away my room is that in the immediate vicinity of JFK, hotel rooms were in extraordinarily short supply. Something about like copies of the National Review on Soviet newsstands, actually. But circa 2:55, a room at the Hampton Inn was found for only $150 more than the original room I'd booked had cost.

Their credit card machine was down, said the guy from Expedia, and anyway Expedia can't do same day bookings, so I'd have to go straight there and give them my card. His voice implied that I seemed nice enough, and he sure hoped I got away before the machine was repaired and they found out I was a deadbeat. I was saddened at the lost opportunity to prove that I can, so, front three c-notes when the occasion requires, but overjoyed at the thought of bed. I jumped into a cab, checked in with lightning speed, and managed to get a solid 3.5 hours of sleep before I had to get back up to make my flight. Unfortunately, there was no real time for frivolities like showers, but thankfully I'm pretty sure the octagenarian in the seat next to me had long ago lost her sense of smell.

The Hampton Inn, JFK, by the way, was lovely: nothing much to look at, but big soft beds and some very helpful clerks who tried to aid me in getting the Comfort Inn, Jamaica, Queens to pay my freight. Sadly, this was to no avail, but they put me up anyway, and this morning, when I overslept slightly and missed the airport shuttle, found me a delightfully insane woman who drove her minivan up onto the sidewalk in an attempt to get me to JFK on time.

Because I thought I owed the clerk the courtesy of checking with the credit card company again, I did so when I finally got to a computer today. I got the same answer, which is that my card had been charged, and no further authorizations attempted. Because I'm a little bit crazy, and also because i already have the technology in order to do phone interviews, I recorded that call. And then I talked again to the people at the Comfort Inn, Jamaica, Queens.

Yes, the man there said, it our records show we tried to authorize your card and failed.

I just spoke to my credit card company and they say that isn't true, I said.

I don't see anything here, he said, with the beginnings of dismissal in his voice.

I recorded the telephone call with the credit card company, I said, as sweetly as I could muster (which, I'm afraid I must confess, wasn't very.) Would you like to listen to it?

I want to get to the bottom of this, he said. Let me check my records and call you back.

Which he just did. And what do you suppose their records show? They show that the Comfort Inn, Jamaica, Queens, charged my card last night sometime between 8 and 9 pm. And then . . . no, it's okay, stop holding your breath . . . did not attempt any further authorizations.

I can't imagine what could have happened, said the manager.

I am so un-cynical about things like this that a friend recently looked at me after a particularly Polly-annaish statement to the effect that people usually make political arguments in good faith, and said, "And what else have you learned about us during your stay on our planet?" Nonetheless, even I, who cannot do math and believes that everyone is a good person, deep down inside, could figure out what had happened: someone had offered her more money for the room. The rain delays at JFK meant that hotels near the airports were packed solid; I chose the Comfort Inn in the first place because it was the classiest of the remaining three hotels available on Expedia. (No, seriously: one of the other places was, last time I looked, known to rent rooms by the hour).

I want to find out what happened, said the manager; I will call you back tomorrow.

I can't wait to hear the explanation for the clerk's vociferous insistence that she had--twice!--attempted to charge my card. The thing demands a rather high degree of artistry. Has she recently gone off her meds, leading to a recurrence of her visual hallucinations? Is she a compulsive liar? Have they confused me with the other Megan McArdle who booked a hotel room at 8 pm yesterday through Expedia? Did God, acting through the credit card machine at the Comfort Inn, Jamaica, Queens, cause it to malfunction so as to force me into a wandering exile?

Obviously, whatever the explanation, it will not make me any less filthy or exhausted, or give me, in retrospect, a more productive day out of my few here. There are only two things I can do: rant to you, and file a new learning away in the indelible memory box: when you have a choice between any "Choice" hotel, particularly a Comfort Inn, and especially the Comfort Inn, Jamaica, Queens, choose the fleabag that rents rooms by the hour. At least the people who mug you there won't try to convince you that it's your fault.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://meganmcardle.theatlantic.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/17224

Comments (112)

Another one to avoid: Super 8 motel, at least the one in Manchester, New Hampshire. I got in at 2AM, and at 7 the phone rang - it was the housekeeping people, wondering if it was a good time to come in and clean the room.
No wonder the rental car guy smirked when I asked him for directions.

Wow, this is the longest blog post ever.

Not to make you feel any worse than you do, but you could have driven from Washington to Rochester in about 7 hours.

Think of the + side, you already have a chapter done for your book about the "S&P 500-ization" of the American Economy.

And to BB's point, driving is highly under-rated.

Are there really people in the world, even your closest relatives and oldest friends, who would take the time to read that entire post on such a mundane topic?

Rewrite: The hotel sold my room. Verrrry irritating.

Please do seek to altruistically punish the guilty. I want to free ride on improved customer service.

Wow, that is terrible. I hope you manage to get her fired or something.

Ostap: Yes.

The clerk is a liar. We won't know if it is compulsive until the next time this happens to you. In general it is a good rule to refuse connecting flights through JFK or LaGuardia. Refuse. Go through Toronto if you must. Even Chicago can work out better.

I hope this has taught you an important metaphorical lesson about the desirability of a national single-payer health care program.

(Kidding. And I'm very sorry for your troubles. Business travel is no fun even on good days, and this was clearly not one of them.)

Let's get the racial/ethnic/immigration status profile on the Comfort Inn clerk so we can tie this in with previous posts about race/IQ/immigration if relevant.

It could have been worse...your luggage could have wound up in Kalamazoo.

Make sure the credit card company does a chargeback to Expedia. You did not receive the merchandise/service for which you paid. I don't care if they say it's "nonrefundable;" you paid for a service you didn't receive. You are not responsible for it.

Next time, check the Weather Channel for the forecast before making last-minute travel plans. You could have rented a car for far less and wasted less time and money (and had less stress!).

Your only mistake, that I can see, was returning to the airport to call your credit card company, etc. If you had made your calls standing in front of the desk, you would have at least given the clerk some moments of concern (if the room was sold in an unauthorized manner). Also, the hotel lobby was probably warmer than the airport.

When I am told my card is refused, I like to call from right there, right then, maximizing the nuisance factor.

Oh, and I thought the post was amusingly written. Making lemonade....

Echoing what others have said: If the trip is less than about 500 or 600 miles, then DRIVE, don't fly. Personally, I would drive even for 800 to 1000 mile business trips, and take a vacation day if I have to. (But of course, I'm in Montana, and the speed limit here is 75 mph.)

My condolences. Similar to what was said above, I don't want to rub it in, but anytime the drive can be made in eight hours or less, it should be considered as an alternative to flying, despite the increased safety risk. If the flying involves connecting with another flight, drive every time. When I live in the southeast for a few years, I gave up trying to connect through Atlanta, and just drove the four hours instead, because about 50% of the team I would end up staying in Atlanta overnight instead, either on the way out, or the way back. They would put me up in the Ramada Inn next to Hartsfield, and I have stayed in malaria ridden, war-torn hellholes, where 7.62 mm ammo is an acceptable form of currency, that were nicer than that dump.

Entertaining post, Megan, even if I'm sorry to hear it happened to you as I've "been there, done that" myself. Hope you get a good night's rest tonight.

oy. and also: ugh.

Don't bother with airport hotels. Just rely on this site. Problem solved.

Megan, I'm sorry you had such a bad experience. I am grateful you wrote about it.

Your experience was worse than my own worst travel story: Feb. 14, 2001, I flew into Chicago for a day trip. I returned to O'Hare for the return flight to Phoenix only to learn that America West had canceled its remaining flights to Phoenix. Since weather caused the cancellation, the airline didn't have to put me on another airline or find me a hotel. (I asked the agent how weather could have caused the cancellation given that other airlines were still flying into Phoenix. "What, are American's pilots better than yours?") At least I was able to find a room at a local hotel and catch the first flight out the next morning, which got me into Phoenix in time for my morning meeting -- wearing the same clothes I'd worn to Chicago the day before.

Rule of thumb 1 - use lowest tech transport congruent with -
Rule of thumb 2: Transit time should never be more that 25% of total trip.

By-the-hour hotels do have interesting "room service" options, though. You have to order off the menu (as opposed to from the menu). Red wine, white wine, champagne, blonde, brunette, redhead, reefer, rock, or meth.

Nasty story, hope it's a long time until yuou have another one like it.

I think you're missing what probably happened about your room though, some other guy came in before you did, and after introducing the clerk to his friend Benny and possibly his twin or triplet brother(s), to the clerk, (not the hotel), the clerk gave away your room. I'd get the money back on your charge, I bet the clerk won't help you with that either, for obvious reasons.

HA! As one who grew up in Rochester, NY (now in Seattle), I am still laughing at your description of the area as the "Exotic wilds of Western New York State."

Hey Megan, once you are in Rochester, check the housing prices. You might be tempted to stay...I know I was the last time I visited after a 10 year absence.

In any sensible society, you would have had every right to strangle that clerk to death and then slept at her home.

Sorry to hear your trip sucked - driving would have been better,but how where you to know....and the weather has really been unexceptional around here as far as I have noticed. If you'd been stuck here in Rochester instead of Jamaica, we could have offered you our couch - well, presumably at least you got to listen to nice Reggae music!

Oh - if you like karaoke, try Dubland Underground Sunday night (after trivia at the Old Toad) - I'll buy you a drink and see if I can find any nice tall boys for you (odds aren't good though).

Don't miss the George Eastman House, and if you have some time, and haven't seen Niagara Falls yet, it is not far.

She (not Comfort Inn) sold your room to a higher bidder $$$$$$$$$$$$$ Cash money no questions asked.

Welcome to New York!

You mention heading toward the "wilds
" of Western New York State and then take several hundred words to describe an experience that we occidental Empire State hicks never experience until we are forced to make connections in the "civilized" part of the country that you inhabit.

Now, that's "wild".

I'm fucking vindictive about such things. If I were you, I would stop at nothing to get the bitch sacked. The scum need to learn. Consider it a service to humanity.

A terrible experience, but a terrific blog post.

Given that Expedia would have billed your card when you booked the room online (at least that's how it's worked when I've used them), I don't see why Comfort Inn would have needed an authorization. At the point you made the reservation you should have had a guaranteed room.

If I'd had your experience, I'd write a letter to Comfort Inn/Choice and Expedia explaining what happened. It seems to me that at the very least they should cover the expense for your room that night, as well as give you an explanation for what the hell happened.

I love Hampton Inns. The only bad experience I've ever had there involved a crazy guy who kept coming back and screaming at the top of his lungs and wandering the halls questioning other guests, and, apparently, the police can't hold you over a certain number of hours for just disturbing the peace, and it's a pain to get a restraining order at 4am on a weekend night (and they have a certain reluctance to do that when it's a platinum executive club person that's screaming.) Incidentally, I remain vaguely terrified of Wyoming thanks to that night.

I reiterate what everyone else said about driving, though. It's faster for us in central Ohio to drive to Washington DC than to fly, especially when you count the time it takes to drive to the airport, pass through security, and add your traffic & chaos pad time. We actually get to the hotel faster even though we have to navigate DC traffic during rush hour, every time we try it (and always to a place we've never been before.) You pretty much need to be crossing the country (or an ocean) to make flying worth it; even traveling directly from one hub city to another doesn't seem to help much.

Not all Hampton Inns are equal. I will never stay at the Hampton Inn in Nashville, TN going toward Memphis again. The inn is operated by immigrants who have no concept of Southern hospitality. The cultural disonance was palpable. The owner and his family treated their employees like subhumans, reprimanding them in front of guests for things not their fault or responsibilty. I wanted to tell them we don't have a caste system in America, but I do find you untouchable. I've never felt more unwelcome or uncomfortable in a hotel before, and I travel a lot in my job.

On the other, the Hampton Inn in Flagstaff, AZ is the best Hampton I've ever visited, both for quality of service and staff.

Hotels, like people, must be judged one-at-a-time, especially if franchised.

Hell hath no fury like a woman wronged whose survival skills go not further than a cell phone and plenty of money. Having gone through similar experiences, I am not impressed. Quite the opposite. Ms. McArdle is soft and weak. I'll just leave it at that.

I think the gnome is actually from Travelocity, not Expedia.

I remember Knoxville, Tenn. fondly.

I got to sleep with over 50 women in one night. On the floor of the airport terminal.

I did have the presence of mind to ask one of the airline personnel to retrieve some sleeping gear from one of the grounded aircraft before they went off duty. At least I was only uncomfortable, not cold and uncomfortable. Others were not so wise.

Sadly none of the grounded ladies asked to share my accommodations.

Ah, the joys of air travel.

LOL

I think I bought your room. It cost me an extra 20 bucks.

I've had this done to me at relatively nice hotels in San Francisco. A convention was in town and I didn't get there before 9 PM. It wasn't even that late. Hotel clerks are evil. What you should have done was offer her 50 bucks for a room and video the exchange on your cell phone, then turn her in to the DA.

Your mistake was not in choice of motel; it was in going by air. D.C. to upstate New York is less than 300 miles. An easy day's travel by car. You bypass two terrible airports as well as NYC itself, otherwise known as The Maw Of Hell. Plus you arrive in far better physical, mental and emotional condition. Having thus also avoided exposure to seventeen deadly plagues from around the globe is a lagniappe.

My rule: anything less than 800 miles I do by car, unless I've got to be there the next day. But next-day travel with an arrival in time enough to be fully rested, calm and prepared for whatever lies ahead is still a roll of the dice by air. So I drive unless I absolutely can't.

Had air travel not become the ordeal it is, Books On Tape would still be used by the vision-impaired only.

This is the easiest thing in the world to explain.

Someone arrived before you with less foresight and more brass, and they bribed someone into selling your room.

it's at this point in time that I hand you a stout glass with three fingers of 30 year old glenfiddich over 2 icecubes, and stand in silent commiseration...

You shoulda told them you were with Knight Ridder.

I might have got this wrong because I didn't read the post carefully enough, but was part of your problem having only one credit card?? If so, this is positively anti-american and highly reprehensible. Please embrace consumer capitalism and get at least 5 credit cards. If nothing else, I'm guessing it's a near combinatorial certainty that one or other credit card computer system will randomly click with one or other vendor system. Ahhh, Purchasing Power ... it's magic

Quit yer bitchin'

I got stiffed by a Rodeway Inn this past August, even after having made a reservation about a year in advance. A cancellation confirmation appeared in my inbox with about a month to go, even though I had never requested one. Seems the rate I was quoted in my original confirmation e-mail was WAY lower than the going rate for a room during the event I had planned to attend, and I suspect that someone connected to the Rodeway location conveniently plugged my name and my confirmation number into the Choice Hotels web site, pulled up the reservation, clicked "Cancel", and voila! Suddenly a room is available that can be offered up for triple the price! After all, who else would be privy to the confirmation number and the last name of the person making the reservation?

I went to mapsonus.com, which says that from Washington, D.C. to Rochester, NY, is about 380 miles. It also says that you can drive it in six hours, which is probably highly optimistic. Call it eight.

So: begin at 3:00 PM. Call up Enterprise Rent-A-Car and tell them what you want. The location at 2601 Calvert offers a Cadillac DTS or Lincoln Town Car for $500 per week, and like most non-airport Enterprise locations will deliver the car to you. (Note: I don't know where you and your editor were. This is just an example.) I am willing to bet that the weekly rental for a luxury car is less than your employers dropped for the flight to JFK alone, let alone nonsense like $60 cab rides to Dulles.

At 4:00 PM you have the car and can begin your trip. (Packing? What packing? --shove stuff in the trunk, sneering at the rollabord the while. Got a gallon of hair gel? Sling it in there.)

Sometime between 10:00 PM and midnight -- i.e., before you ever left Dulles, as you did it -- you arrive in Rochester. If a 6 AM flight out of JFK to Rochester, with following cab ride, got you to your destination in time, it means that you could have gone to bed, slept until 7:00 or 8:00 AM, had a leisurely shower and breakfast, and gotten to your meeting in plenty of time, either driving yourself or by cab.

During the "several days" you intend to be in Rochester, you would have had the car available at no extra cost for jaunts to wherever you wanted to go. At the end of the trip you would drive home, gawking at the beautiful fall foliage and stopping occasionally for pictures, return the car, and go comfortably to bed. If you should need to shorten your trip, no worries at all -- when you return the car they change the bill. Should you need to extend it, call the local Enterprise office (not the airport location) and extend your reservation. No need to call India or speak to the airline's phone robot.

Traveling by air is bad enough at the best of times. When it includes changing planes in the U.S. Northeast it is a heart-throbbingly frustrating experience involving phone robots, surly clerks in all kinds of places you'd rather not visit anyway, and delay, delay, delay. The phrase "connects at JFK", translated from airlinish to English, means "does not connect". The correct response when a travel agent or reservation clerk uses those words is "F* off and die" followed by hanging up or leaving as quickly as possible, whichever is appropriate.

No, I don't work for Enterprise Rent-A-Car, but I've been in love with them for twenty years.

Regards,
Ric

Wow
Another naive victim of traveling through the eastern hubs of the US

Say out loud now
a)Never book a connecting flight out of NYC after 3 pm.
b) Never use expedia to make a late night hotel -call the hotel direct-that way when they screw up you can yell at them by name and acquaintance.
c)Always have a backup--like rental car or stay at home
d) I have never had a 5:00 am flight be late. Always try early in the am rather then late in the day

I hope you have a good time here in Rochester. The leaves are turning and the weather is good for this time of year.

Or, if you can't stand to drive that far, and have some time to spare, the train is always an option.

The train from DC to Rochester is slower than driving or flying (Amtrak has 4 departure times most days, with a change in NYC and total one-way itinerary of 11-12 hours). But you can use the time to work on things like writing your stories somewhere that has ample seat space (or a lounge table) and an outlet to plug into on most trains. And when you're not working, you can relax. (You can't write while you drive, and working in the air usually involves cramped quarters and battery constraints.) The late train from NYC has full-service dining and sleeping accommodations too, if you want them.

It's not something that works for all trips, particularly when you're in a hurry, but it's often worth considering when you're not.

I think this is a common practice when booking on the internet. I booked at a Holiday Inn express on Expedia over a memorial day weekend in San Antonio. It was about a block from the river walk.

When I went to check in, I noticed a couple standing to the side just waiting. I gave my name to the clerk, she said very dismissively, "sorry we have no record of your reservation, we are full," and than she turned away as if I would just disappear or something.

I very sweetly pulled my copy of the reservation out and showed her that I was indeed booked and in fact had already paid. Suddenly she had a room. I think the couple standing to the side was going to be given my room or a room that someone else had booked over the Internet.

Well, Megan doesn't OWN a car, remember?

OTOH, according to amtrak's website, it's about a 10 hr train ride 3.25 from union station to penn station, and then another 7 to rochester from there.

Hell, I'd take the train to NYC *anyway* - it's likely faster door-to-door; given check-in times. Even if you're going to take the plane from NYC to Rochester. (I doubt it's any cheaper though). It's a hell of a lot easier to make it from U st to union station via metro, IIRC than to make it to national. And IMHO, the seats are better on the train.

I know whereof I speak, because I used to take the eastern corridor from newark to union station for trips home from college; I wish I could afford to do that rather than drive these days when I go home to visit my familiy

Bummer. But man, posting this is like issuing a clarion call to every poster on your site to find some way to use the story to affirm their own ideological prejudices.

I apologize for failing to resist the temptation, but...maybe train, next time? Saves a lot of carbon too. Though I confess I don't know what trying to get to Rochester by train is like.

I got all caught up in your plight, Megan, and relished how you followed through rather than shrug it off as many people would have done. My secret and uncharitable hope is that the clerk finds herself in deep unCOMFORTable doo doo.

I'll go along with what others have said. Unless I have no choice, I drive. You can easily make 900 miles in a day. I truly believe the airlines are running some kind of bizarre experiment to see how badly you can treat people and still have them return.

I agree with the thoughts expressed by the Punisher. And, indeed, in the strongest possible terms, I recommend that you find out the name of the lying hotel clerk (it's probably etched in your brain), and -- for god sakes! -- LIST IT prominently in your post. Then email your URL to the VP of the hotel chain and, heck, email it to her personally if you can figure her email address. Let her know that this incident is now a permanent fixure on Google that will arise any time anyone (a future employer, perhaps) googles her. You do no one any favors by politely and generously shielding her from the consequences of her sleazy behavior.

Megan, you need to take effective action!

First, set up a Web page or a new, separate blog post dedicated to your bad experience with Comfort Inn, consisting of this blog entry but with the introductory material condensed to three or four sentences. You did get the desk clerk's name, didn't you? Publish it here.

Second, go to as many "travel guide" websites as you can find (Google will give you a bunch if you simply enter "Comfort Inn Jamaica Queens"). For example, one such is tripadvisor.com. Each such site usually provides an opportunity for travelers to give reviews of the facilities. Use it! Paste in a short message that gives the gist of your complaint, and link to the new blog post.

Then, send the URL of this new blog post to the manager of the Comfort Inn at Jamaica, Queens ... and to sundry Choice International representatives, including the media relations people and as many VPs as you can find. Be sure to let them know that you're an internationally known journalist with millions of readers and a blogger who gets tens of thousands of hits a day ... and that your post about Comfor Inn has been linked by your good personal friend Glenn Reynolds, the Instapundit.

Then let them try to make it up to you ... &sp; ;-)

Not to make you feel any worse than you do, but you could have driven from Washington to Rochester in about 7 hours.


Posted by Bruce Bartlett | October 25, 2007 5:21 PM

And give up the convenience of flying?

Yeah, I would have driven also.
My family still holds a grudge against Howard Johnson's from 40+ years ago. We checked in, spent the night. The next day we went to disneyworld and when we came back to our hotel, there were other people in our room. The hotel had rented it out even though we were booked for the week.

I booked a room at a business hotel in St Louis a year or so ago. Prepaid. Drove from Wichita but didn't arrive in St Louis until 3am. The clerk refused to give me a room because I was "too late" and he had started night audit. Previously the hotel had checked me in and made the key and put it in a envelope for my arrival, since it wasn't a held room but a prepaid room. I made a major fuss and they finally gave me a room using the maid key.

Finally, last November the weekend of the Big 12 championship football game I got a room in Lawrence just down the road. I arrived to find the hotel had burned down the night before. No one called to tell me. Every hotel room within 75 miles were booked up and the guy on the expedia line told me that I had to call the hotel. The one that burned down.

I feel that bad service is a sign of full employment and a healthy economy. None of which makes you feel better while sleeping in your car.

Considering you had paid for the room (assuming I got the story right) and considering had you not shown up they would have kept the money, it sounds a lot like they broke a contract with you. I hate the idea of suing every time you turn around, but on stuff like this, what other choice do you have if they refuse to take responsibility for their actions and make it right?

BTW - if you haven't paid for your return ticket yet; consider at least taking the train back from NYC... (hell, even if you have).

How sad nobody suggested the use of a travel agent. Things like this happens when you ignore professionals. Better luck next time.

This may not be the most lavish option but I beleive Greyhound bus travels to Rochester several times a day from NYC for about $80. Travel time is about 6 hours. No Internet access I know of but at least you can write and relax.

Welcome to NY -- I agree with the comment that she is a liar and some guy who slipped her $20 was sleeping in your bed. Everyone here in NY makes up lies like that. Do what I do in here: Just tell her shes a freaking liar and start screaming at her until she gives in,

now that you've had that scotch... I'd consider renting a car in rochester and returning to dulles or reagan... according to budget... a basic economy for focus, which is a pretty nice little car, can be had for $65...

even if it was more than that, it's worth it, really. 8hrs drivetime through the fall foliage, nobody falling asleep on your shoulder, no 2 hour security line, no travellers cold. And if the numbers are correct 1/30 the carbon spewed by the plane for your seat high into the atmo...

I dunno if you might REALLY hate driving... I have friends that do... but it's something to think on, even if that $100 [including gas etc.] comes out of your pocket...

because you are going to spend that 8hours at various airports ANYWAY.

Don't be so negative toward Megan. I've been traveling extensively for 30 years now and this VERY SAME Comfort Inn is the worst hotel I've ever stayed in (unfortunately after a long, exhausing flight back from Ghana). Amazingly rude, actually frightening desk clerks. If she'd gotten a room, it would have been no treat, believe me. It made me long for the luxuries of West Africa.

I can't imagine why Comfort Inn, which I've always found reliable, doesn't close this hellhole of a property.

which was storm in like the gnome in the television commercials and save me

The Gnome only works in Zurich..... sorry, he works for Travelocity.

My worst travel story involves pre-deregulation travel from Grand Rapids, MI to Dallas, TX. I flew a Republic 19 seat puddle jumper from GR to O'Hare in Chicago, making 2 stops along the way. We weren't allowed to deplane. It was summer and in the 90s. No AC. I got to O'Hare with about 1.5 hours before my flight. I was carrying 1) a hanging bag with my clothes, 2) a catalog case full of tools (I installed minicomputers in medical labs and had to be able to build cables and troubleshoot custom interface boxes) that included screwdrivers, wire cutters and a wire wrap tool that looked like a gun with a barrel the size of a pencil lead, 3) an oscilloscope, and 4) a case of beer wrapped in brown paper (a present from the lab techs I had worked with). I had to go from the end of one terminal to the farthest domestic terminal. Or so I thought. I hiked to the other terminal, about 1.5 miles with all my stuff, got to the Braniff terminal, and saw that the flight was leaving from the far end of the International departures terminal. Another mile or so to walk.


Although this was the late 70s, there was still some security due to all the flights hijacked to Cuba. I got to the international terminal had to go through international departure security explaining why I had all these tools with me. And a case of beer. I got to the gate about 30 minutes before departure and heard an announcement that the flight had changed gates. Back to the domestic area, 2 terminals away.

I was now on the wrong side of international departures. The only way back was via Immigration and Customs, which had a huge line. I went back to the terminal security post and managed to talk my way back through the post the wrong way, mainly because they still remembered me.

I schlepped back to the domestic departure area, to find the flight was delayed. There was no food and they were short on drinks also. And the flight was coming back over evening thundershowers, so drink service was cut off due to turbulence.

Braniff went belly up shortly after this.

I can't imagine why Comfort Inn, which I've always found reliable, doesn't close this hellhole of a property.


Posted by Doug Herbert | October 25, 2007 11:54 PM

Unfortunately, in that location they could make a profit renting iron cots and saying, "What the F--- do YOU want?" whenever a customer came in.

Complaints do little for a profitable operation that thinks it has a lock on the market. If they had more empty beds more often, they would be forced to look to service.

You think that's bad? How about the disproportionate impact on women and minorities?

Leah -- "Wow, that is terrible. I hope you manage to get her fired or something."

I think Megan is doing her best with this post to see that Megan is fired.

Wonderful post! Thanks to InstaPundit, I got here. And, then I copied it ... to send it to others; who love it ... when words make ya laugh.

I hope you take this idea of copying what you've done; and sending this to the CEO of Comfort Inn. And, Hampton Inn.

Let the addresses be obvious.

Let them "feel" the humor!

Lots of good advice in the comments of others. Hey! I never knew you could "sleep" at airports; visiting cities. And, cutting out the middle men!

Please don't get her fired, she may just show up as an M.A. to a gastroenterologist.

you really need to get someone fired for this whetherh manager or the receptionist- these kind of scum try and mistreat customers all the time-so loads of people less influential than you will have suffered like this. You need to threane the hotel chain with exposure of this hotel unless they get to the bottom of this and prevent this every happebning again.

I'm quite serious otherwise this will happen to scores of other people who will suffer in the same way.

This made me really angry and i've never even met you!

Thanks for the update. I won't ever be staying at the Comfort Inn. What an awful experience at least we learned something.

"I think Megan is doing her best with this post to see that Megan is fired."

So who runs that Comfort Inn? Masons? The Knights Templar? Matt Yglesias? Whoever it is, they must have a lot of influence at the Atlantic.

The worst thing I ever had happen was on a road trip up to Lansing, MI from my home in Iowa. I was towing a trailer (longish story) and finally found a place where I could park the trailer-plus-car and get into the motel. After ringing the desk bell four or five times, I managed to rout out the clerk, who charged my card and gave me a key.

I went to let myself in---and the door was chained shut, and there was someone else in there. (Asleep, with the TV on; that was how I knew what had happened.) I went back to the front desk, expecting to be given a different room, but couldn't rout out that damn clerk at all. I stayed around for a while, sharing my tale of woe with others who came in (surprise surprise, none of them seemed interested in staying) and finally left the key on the desk with a note explaining the situation. I ended up staying in Lansing; Motel 6 is your friend.

This happened in April 2002, at the Arbor Inn in Marshall, Michigan; Anila Rana was the owner. I've kept the card all these years.

Very, very sorry. Sounds like a terrible experience, and indeed, the state of the New York airport system is a shame for the entire nation.

For your personal experience, is the answer, a rule change saying that airlines have to put people up even if weather is the cause of the delay? I have had miserable experiences with airlines claiming weather, even when, as pointed out above, the claim is dubious. Moreover, airlines have strong bargaining power with hotels near airports - can deliver tons of passengers + crew, while we're just single guests that don't register on the numbers of most corporations.

Had an experience like this in Rome, Italy, where airlines cannot plead weather, and it was grand - was at the Hilton with the pilots, because the airlines pay such a low rate they could put us there. It was an improvement and is a small regulatory change (in an already decently heavily regulated industry, mind you) that could lead to a big improvement.

Dear Comfort Inns,

Welcome to the 21st Century! Where shafting your customer and lying about it ends up on a blog, linked by Instapundit and read by approximately 98% of your potential customer base. Which is now considerably smaller than it was yesterday. For all your hotels, not just the flea-trap in Queens.

Have a nice day.

Your Friend,
The Internet

I was going to suggest that the clerk was probably compelled not by dollars (and the risk of exchanging future income and job for immediate pocket change) but by management to "keep all the rooms filled." And like airlines, with their seating algorithms that are perfectly willing to rook you out of a flight, so too, some managers at hotels will make that type of command decision if the hour is late and you are not checking in every moment with an ETA.

I don't travel often, but my worst hotel stay was in Virginia. We ended up at a hotel in Williamsburg near the entrance to either Busch Gardens or a related water park. The hallways were dark, and everything seemed to be damp from water. It may have been a Hilton. Me, my sister and nieces checked in, got up to the room, felt very dirty, very "The Shining", and from there, called around to an Embassy Suites, and checked right out. I love Embassy Suites.


What I wonder is how many time/dollar hours Megan has spent trying to get justice.

Funniest response to a bad hotel stay:

"Yours is a Very Bad Hotel"
http://www2.oakland.edu/users/oakley/Teaching_files/Yours%20Is%20a%20Very%20Bad%20Hotel.pdf

Classic.

Working at hotels for the past four years I could regail you with stories of all kinds.

Sh*t guests, sh*t coworkers, stupid mistakes from all people (including myself), but Ms. McArdle's problem was bad. Very bad. Being the night guy, I've had to cancel rooms because the card was bad. Usually it's not a big deal. Week nights we get sold out and I don't see anyone so I leave it be. Weekends are pretty dead, pleanty of rooms so I leave it be. They show up or not it's not gonna change nothing. They do show some of the time and then it's all good. I've never canceled a guaranteed reservation just to sell to someone else at any price. That's just wrong on so many levels. The deal was made and the deal needs to be honored, that's how I look at it.

Also I wouldn't use Expedia or any of those other sites either nor do I recommend them. They suck.

Oh, and the guy who said Indians (or "immigrants" at any rate) treat their employees like shit? Dude, you don't...even...know. Well, it's not nearly entirely true. Most of 'em here in this town, and I've worked for a few of 'em, are generally cool. Generally. The guy I work for I've had so few problems with. One hotel, and I'll name it, Best Western/Casavilla Suites, man those people are tyrants. The GM is always screwing around on his wife and always having the front desk staff cover for his philandering ass. They don't wanna put any money back into the hotel so everything suffers and then let the staff get bitched out. Turnover rate at that place...man, people last only a couple of months. If it's not people quitting it's people getting accused of shit out of the blue and fired. My friend got accused of doing drugs. I got accused of stealing...man, one guy put in his two weeks and instead of letting him finish out his tenure they just fired him on the spot! Not that he did anything wrong it's just how they are.

Yeah, treating their employees as subhuman would accurately describe it.

But like I said, I've worked with Indians that are decent. But man, the bad ones are horrible.

Megan, about all you can do here after the fact is call/e-mail the corporate people for Choice Hotels and report the Comfort Inn From Hell to them. If it's simply an independently-owned hotel affiliated the chain and there have been other similar problems, the can threaten to pull its license, which would end up costing the hotel potential customers down the line, or if it's a company-owned hotel they could (if they care) go in and change management and find someone who actually gives a damn.

As far as alternate transportation goes, back in ye olden days when I was traveling from New York to Syracuse to attend college, Greyhound ran frequently from the Port Authority to upstate from the city -- a 4 1/2 hour trip, while the Canadian bus company Voyageur had the franchise for the Washington, D.C. to Ottawa run. That meant everybody shuffled at Binghamton; those headed for Syracuse, Watertown or Canada transfered to the Voyageur bus, while people coming from D.C headed to Ithaca, Rochester and Buffalo switched from it to Greyhound for the rest of the way. Total time for the D.C.-Rochester trip was about 7-8 hours, if I remember right. That's faster than Amtrak (albeit less classy), though at least now it does operate all its service out of N.Y. Penn Station -- prior to 15 years ago, you had to navigate from Penn Station to Grand Central to travel from D.C. to Rochester by train.

I would think the bus is still the better alternative, barring snowstorms, but I suppose if you're 6-feet-2 and need lots of leg room, eight hours stuck in a cramped bus seat might even be more painful than the Jamaica, N.Y., Comfort Inn. At least Amtrak allows you to walk around and -- theoretically at least -- should be the most reliable transportation option in bad weather conditions.

First mistake: booking a late flight, especially with a plane change. At 5 am, the airplanes are virtually all where they are supposed to be and in working order. With the airlines all trying to run at 100% capacity, it's bound to steadily go down from there, as each delay causes other delays. A plane change at 10 PM probably isn't going to happen, not unless the second airplane also got delayed until 2 am.

Second mistake: Don't just trust an internet travel service, call the hotel and confirm that everything is AOK with your reservation, and that the night clerk knows you're coming in very late. Write down the name of the clerk you talked to.

Incidentally, I was in a Comfort Inn in a small town in Indiana just three weeks ago. The only issue was that their free wireless internet service seemed to require logging back in several times an hour. But I arrived at a reasonable time, because I drove.

I'm genuinely surprised that I don't see many comments to the effect of "Giving away your room to someone willing to pay more for it is right in line with the libertarian pro-market philosophies that you espouse. Hotel rooms were a scare resource, and it went to the highest bidder, as it should."

Not that I believe that - the real problem wasn't the hotel room going to a higher bidder, but rather the manner in which the transaction was conducted, and the fact that you were not notified.

Still, I'm surprised not to see many of the "welcome to capitalism!" digs.