« Incidentally | Main | Vouching for vouchers »

Plus ca change . . .

29 Oct 2007 07:55 am

Terry Teachout writes:

My mother's life, in short, is a bridge between two profoundly, almost unimaginably different worlds. A child of the Great Depression, she was raised on a farm and baptized in a river, and has lived long enough to watch me talk on a computer screen, though she's never owned a computer of her own. Cake mixes and air conditioning are more her speed. The most recent inventions of any significance that she embraced wholeheartedly were the answering machine, the ATM, and the VCR. (She has a DVD player but never uses it.)

I suppose we all reach a moment in our lives when we lose interest in the new, and I suspect that moment comes sooner for technology than for art. For now I seem to be staying fairly open to new things--my experience as a blogger suggests as much--but I have yet to send my first text message, nor does my somewhat superannuated cellphone contain a digital camera. On the increasingly rare occasions when I feel the need to take a picture of something, I buy a disposable film camera, the postmodern equivalent of a Brownie, at the corner drugstore.

I'm not sure he doesn't have it backwards. Right now, I remain an avid consumer of new art and new technology . . . I just installed my first NAS this weekend. But music is the most pervasive form of art that most people consume, and most people I know stop listening to new music in their late twenties or early thirties, long before they're done buying DVD players and flat panel televisions. They do consume new books and new movies, but their patience with new styles seems to evaporate. And most people prefer the relentlessly unvarying style of Thomas Kinkade to a trip through the MOMA.

Comments (13)

Do tell us about your NAS!

Here's the question I'm always left to ponder: do you become a) the old loser who goes to see the Rolling Stones and Allman Brothers 30 years after yo first got into them, and listen to the same tired songs and never experience something new; or b), be that old loser at the club who tries to act with it and cool by going to the latest hip concert and doesn't realize everyone is staring at him? Maybe you can be the cool old dude who goes to the show of the hot new band and hangs in the bar in the back and just sort of bops his head and is inconspicuous.

mmm, I'm going to argue that it is all about technology that you want to use because it does something you need. Most of us only need computers because our lifestyle evolved to use them... Megan, you're kinda a young'n, but you still remember when we didn't HAVE computers or cell phones. They arrived on the scene early enough in our lives that we picked them right up. The previous generation though can take it or leave it, because they never formed their lives around them. So you have people like my mom who use a computer everyday at work, and so forth, but really keeps in touch with people by phone, rather than email, and generally doesn't tune her cell on, unless she needs it. Contrast that with a current teen that texts as if it was breathing, and has the Cell glued to their ear.

I do agree that many people get to a point where they don't listen to the new music as much, but that may be sheer volume of music available and changing tastes. I like most the music of my youth because of the impression it made on me at the time. Once you get into that adult stage where you are so busy with life that music is a passing fancy, you MISS a lot of the newer stuff, because you just don't have time to spend an entire evening listening to music. iTunes has changed the dynamic a bit, since you can get a single without getting burned by an album that sucks, but still. The expanse of music is exponential, and that means that people really grab their small slice.

I mean how many people listen to ska anymore? I mean besides me? Or actual punk?

On the other hand, I seem to suddenly be listening to Japanese bands because I like a certain beat that I picked up from Anime... or something else that tugs the ear, like the Yoshida Brothers [rock Shamisen? sure Rising ]

I found them by cruising youtube for fan vid from an anime, and once I liked the music, I went looking for it. Heh, it's almost like latenight college radio, where they'd play anything... or WXRT back in the day.
sheesh, now I do sound old...

Freddie says:

Here's the question I'm always left to ponder: do you become a) the old loser who goes to see the Rolling Stones and Allman Brothers 30 years after yo first got into them, and listen to the same tired songs and never experience something new;

I dunno, how are the shows? I've always assumed that shows of this type basically suck.

or b), be that old loser at the club who tries to act with it and cool by going to the latest hip concert and doesn't realize everyone is staring at him? Maybe you can be the cool old dude who goes to the show of the hot new band and hangs in the bar in the back and just sort of bops his head and is inconspicuous.

Who cares what a bunch of know nothing kids think? One of the benefits of becoming a crusty old dude is that you just do not care. For that matter, I find it hard to believe that the kids even notice the existence of anybody who doesn't appear to be either a potential sexual partner or a potential sexual rival.

One of the benefits of becoming a crusty old dude is that you just do not care.

True!

Megan,
I was with you right up until you mentioned He Who Shall Remain Nameless So I Don't Lose My Breakfast. The infestation of Kinkade (urp!) & his ilk is a constant threat to my gallery browsing in strange cities, since one never know where he might be lurking. I know the ice cream is free here, but could you please refrain from topping my serving with dryer lint?
Yr fthfl svnt....

D: I was bouncing around the house last night to the Mighty Mighty Bosstones' Pay Attention. You're not alone.

I'm going to disagree with Terry. I see and hear new "music" at the gymn and I like some of it but rap?

Thump, thump. You're a whore and you snore and I can't take no more. Thump thump. music or torture?

No, I've even tracked down and bought some CDs of the theme songs from some Japanese TV shows because I like the melodies.

I never thought I needed a GPS until I got one. For a mere $200, I never need to listen to "why don't you stop and ask directions" again. Digital camera? I like technology, just not enough to pay the premium to be an early adopter.

Let's just say I was in eighth grade when JFK was killed. I'm old enough to have confidence in my own tastes and opinions, but not too old to try new things.

hey, in honor of Boston's impending win (I'm a Blue Jays fan actually but a baseball fan first) I went for a ran and bopped around the apartment to Question the Answers AND Ska-Core, the Devil, and More yesterday!

My Gran was a child of the Great Depression - well a teenager - and has had a computer, an internet connection, and an email account for several years now.

An important thing to remember is that technology changes much faster than music. Even accounting for the variety of already-existing music, there will be stuff in 10 years we haven't imagined yet.

As far as music, I think the thing is to try to find something that speaks to you now, rather than reliving the past through your particular oldies. People seem to associate a given song or piece of music with the time they got familiar with it. It seems odd that we would prefer revisiting some resonance of high school or grad school or whatever, rather than finding something new. Perhaps we're more emotional or passionate when younger and we have trouble matching our established connections with music. So maybe that means training yourself to see music as a bit more of an intellectual, or hihgbrow pursuit (classical, anyone?), or just find something you can dig now in a more visceral way. Me, I listen to a vast array of electronica, dance, and instrumental music. I have no idea why.

There is a way in which "new" art is all the same. A taste for the "new" is simply having a taste for a certain style. Order me up a remix with shock frosting, please.

There are times I come across a show of edgy new painters -- and not only are their antecedents obvious, but the gimics they use to seem relevant are obvious too. Over in this gallery is a landscape painter -- but she only paints toxic waste sites! Across the hall is the guy who has re-embraced the figure!

Once you lose your taste for the new, there's a lot of really good old stuff to discover. Good old stuff in many different styles.

3.blogspot.com buy viagra


Copyright © 2008 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.